Don't you think,captain Dhoni...?

No , i don't think so.

everyone have their own style of leadership Dhoni is different , he isn't someone who will always look to be politically correct.

He has said many times in interviews that he is openly critical about the players , and he never wants them to take things easily and yes he has done that in the past as well .

Do you Remember how he criticized Rohit sharma in Australia for not running properly between the wickets when he was acting as his runner. and how he criticized Piyush chawla , or munaf patel (on the field).

http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/I-am-openl...

to quote dhoni

"More importantly I have a good rapport with my team, they respond well to me and that is why they understand me. After the end of every match I speak to them,"

and,After that every player performed well in that CB series.

Did you bring this up then?

if you did then please tell me when?

--------------------------

you are saying he should concentrate on bringing the best out of them ,

What do you think he is doing now?

Is he not concentrated enough on doing this?

Everyone respect him in the team , you don't get that if your players don't like you for being openly critical.

players listen to him.

---------------------

"I am afraid this will produce only negative results."

Why it didn't produce only negative results in the past?

Why we didn't question him when he was doing this earlier? , was it because he was not losing then?

How much "negative" results it produced earlier ?

Doesn't he praise them when they do well?

Has any captain achieved so much (as dhoni) in such a short time by not criticizing their players in public ?

criticizing the players in public by captain doesn't make them play badly , being international players they should be able to handle this.

And he isn't doing that everyday or after every match, is he?

this has been going on from past 2 or 3 series continuously that bowlers are going for way too many runs at the death overs.

And he also criticized them when they were winning.

http://www.mynews.in/News/Dhoni_concerned_over_fie...

so its not only after losing , he is "blaming" them.He was equally aware of this in good times as well.

He knows when to criticize them in public ,and when to advise them in private.

It's not his Job to act and lead as per yours or everyone's expectations ,it doesn't matter what we think. He will do his job the way he wants , he knows better.

It's funny

that some People don't notice these things when their team is winning, and when you lose a game or two ,then they start pointing fingers..

edit- as the link says , he is also indicating fielders , that's why Robin singh was sacked , as for bowlers they are hit for sixes and in the gaps during death overs , he can't set fielding in the air to protect sixes.

edit- I perfectly understood what you were trying to say and that's why I didn't accept it, and i guess I'm not the only one here who disagrees with some of your views.

However, i agree that situation could have been handled better in T20 WC in 'England'.But, Dhoni was not the only one responsible for giving explanation , he must have consulted the team and Board before messing with media.

It's unfortunate that being a captain one is blamed for everything even when others behind the scenes are equally responsible.some Media persons write spicy headlines and many people fall for it , specially those fair weather fans or who have some personal grudge against them.(not indicating you)

WELL Well well, MISTAKE, Mistake, mistake.

Mistake From Many (NOT Just captain Dhoni) Selector As Well.

Indian Fielding Mistake As well,Indian Batsman Mistake As well.

First MISTAKE is In Vadodara ODI ,Y. Pathan Should Be In Team.

Soooooooooooooooooooooo,

Any Way AUSTRALIAN TEAM IS STRONGER Then TEAM"INDIA"

Dhoni must stop blaming his bowlers & try to look at his own mistakes.Wasn't of Bhajji & Praveen-india would have had to surrender a convincing defeat-he should thank them for the brave fight they put up!

Maybe, but captains are pestered by the media for comment & when they do make a small comment the media blow it up into a major story. So I take anything I read or hear in the media with a grain of salt.

Yes. You are right. Of late, he started commenting too much about his own team. That should be stopped. Instead, he can ask for advice from seniors/experts what to do on improving performance.

poor Dhoni can not be productive for team. I am sure the team was winning because of yovraj, sehwag, Jahir, Ishant etc.. Dhoni's contribution in making team india no 02 in ICC ranking is 0

http://the2012end.blogspot.com/

Its Ok to some extent to blame the team..But not always and also he tells that he is Satisfied with performs of the team..

yeah he should do that also shold point out his mistakes

if he was there india would hv been in a far better position and wud have won the Match against australia

Yes.Many matches india losed was result of his decisions.

Its not just Dhoni, almost every captain do that after defeat.